REMBAUM'S ASSOCIATION ROUNDUP | The Community Association Legal News You Can Use

561-241-4462    |    9121 N. Military Trail, Ste. 200   |   Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410

Important Information for New and Existing Board Members

EDUCATION REQUIREMENTS

As election season will soon be at hand, it is always a good idea to review both initial certification and continuing board member education requirements. There are significant differences as related to condominium board members as compared to homeowner association board members for both the board certification class and the continuing education requirements, as you can see in the chart below.

Throughout the year Kaye Bender Rembaum P.L. offers free board member certification courses as well as continuing education courses for all attendees on a rotating schedule so that you can enjoy one or more of them from the privacy of your own home. To view the calendar, use your browser to visit KBRLegal.com.

RULES and POLICIES EVERY BOARD SHOULD CONSIDER ADOPTING

If you wait until you actually need any of the types of rules and policies discussed below, then in all likelihood you have waited too long. The purpose of adopting the rules and policies discussed below is to provide for the orderly operation of your association so that your day-to-day activities are not encumbered by one or more cantankerous association members whose sole purpose is to wreak havoc upon the board.

A. OFFICIAL RECORD REQUESTS RULES

The board should consider adopting rules regarding official record requests and where and how such requests must be sent. Absent that, a member could send an email or scribble their request on a napkin and give it to a board member triggering the statutory timeline for a response, which can lead to financial penalties for failure to timely make the requested records available for inspection and copying. Such rules can also take into account the permitted frequency of official record requests from a member as well as maximum time to perform such inspections.

Condominium associations should also consider adopting similar rules regarding written inquiries received from an owner via certified mail as failure to properly respond can lead to the association not being able to collect attorneys’ fees and costs in the event of later litigation that was the subject matter of the written inquiry received via certified mail. Such rules can also take into account that each subpart of a question counts as a separate individual question, thereby providing for a total number of questions, including all subparts, to not exceed 20 in total.

B. BOARD AND MEMBERSHIP MEETING DECORUM RULES

These rules can assist business being conducted in an orderly fashion at meetings and can include, without limitation, when the members have the right to speak, a time limit for owner statements (such as three minutes), and other important conduct provisions. Failure to follow such rules leads to the member being excused from the meeting, pending the circumstances. In addition, these rules can also provide for board member decorum as well.

C. ADOPTION OF A COLLECTIONS POLICY

Essentially, having a standardized collections policy ensures that not only are all owners treated similarly in regard to a delinquency, but also it provides for timely and standardized procedures. Such a policy can provide for such things as sending a reminder letter when an owner is a certain number of days past due (such as 15 days), followed by a continuing instruction to management to send the notice of late assessment if the debt is not paid within 30 days of the first letter. If the owner still has not satisfied their delinquency prior to the expiration of the 30 days of the notice of late assessment, then management is instructed to turn the matter over to the association’s attorney to begin collection/foreclosure proceedings, which are so authorized by the collections policy. Such a policy would also include the appropriate interest rate and late fees to be charged in accordance with the association’s governing documents. 

As a reminder, the Florida legislature enacted requirements not too long ago that the association provide one final 30-day notice to a delinquent member before commencing collection and foreclosure activities. This is referred to as a notice of late assessment (NOLA). Upon request the association’s attorney can prepare detailed instructions and provide draft forms so as to ensure statutory compliance.

COLLECTION and FORECLOSURE ACTIVITIES

Your board is reviewing delinquencies and discovers that certain members are very delinquent with their payment of assessments. The manager is instructed to turn those files over to the association’s law firm to begin collection-related activities. Because the burden of proof is on the association to prove the debtor is delinquent, all supporting information regarding the delinquency should be part of the turnover file given to the attorney, which includes providing the “basis” or “backup,” if you will, to substantiate the monies due to the association. Therefore, typically the association needs to provide the following documentation to its attorney as a part of the collection turnover package to commence collection related activities:

      1. A copy of the debtor’s ledger that goes back to the last zero balance (in other words, the ledger showing the last time the owner was not delinquent).
      2. A copy of the notice of late assessment as required by Florida law (and the affidavit of mailing, if available).
      3. If a special assessment is included on the ledger, then a copy of the meeting notice that was posted and mailed to all of the members at least 14 days in advance, the resulting meeting minutes and the notice that was sent to the membership advising that the special assessment was adopted/passed, and the due dates.
      4. If a fine is included on the ledger, and the declaration permits fines to be converted into an assessment, then all of the backup paperwork must be provided, which would include the notice of board meeting where the fine was considered, a copy of the correspondence sent to the owner at least 14 days prior to the fining committee meeting, the minutes resulting from the fining committee hearing, and a copy of the correspondence sent to the owner thereafter advising them as to the debt owed. In addition, depending on the exact language in the declaration, it may be necessary for the board to actually take official action to convert the fine into an assessment (please note that a fine can only potentially be converted into an assessment for a homeowners’ association governed by Chapter 720, F.S.). It is not always automatic, even if the language might lead the ordinary reader to believe as much, and at times it is still necessary to convert the fine into an actual assessment. With that in mind, it is always a good idea to discuss whether your declaration permits the fine to automatically be treated as an assessment, or if other action is required by the board to do so. And remember, unless the declaration provides the authority for the fine to be treated as an assessment, then it cannot be collected as an assessment. Rather, the association would have to resort to other collection means such as small claims court to collect the fine.

The association’s attorney will be a tremendous resource to the board and will play an integral role with assisting the board in conforming all of the above-discussed rules and regulations and policies to your association.

Rain, Rain…Go Away!

[Nov. 3, 2026] | As I write this, the roads in my neighborhood are flooded. Without a large truck, no one is going anywhere. It has been reported that some areas received extraordinary amounts of rain in only a matter of hours. As far as I know, none of my neighbors’ homes flooded, although I would not be surprised to learn that a few garages took on water.

The finger-pointing and accusations have already started.

Without even a basic understanding of what just happened, some residents are threatening to sue their Association and management company. The frustration is understandable. When your street looks like a river and water is approaching your home, you want an explanation. You want someone to fix it. And, perhaps most naturally, you want someone to blame.

But sometimes the culprit is not the Association, the manager, a clogged drain, or a broken pump.

Sometimes there is simply too much water and nowhere for it to go.

The torrential rains that fell over the last several days wreaked havoc across large portions of Florida. Community after community experienced flooded roads, overwhelmed drainage systems and, in some unfortunate instances, water intrusion into homes.

What many Floridians do not realize is that water standing temporarily in streets, swales, lakes and other designated areas does not necessarily mean the drainage system has failed. Those areas are often components of the storm-water-management system itself.

So, before blaming your community association because the street in front of your house looks more suitable for a kayak than a car, it helps to understand where all that water is supposed to go.

YOUR COMMUNITY’S DRAINAGE SYSTEM DOES NOT EXIST IN A VACUUM

When an extraordinary amount of rain falls in a very short period, the problem is not simply getting water into a storm drain. The problem is what happens to the water after it gets there. That distinction is critical.

Florida’s drainage infrastructure is better understood as a series of interconnected systems. Rain falls on homes, roofs, driveways, sidewalks, parking lots and streets. Some of it soaks into the ground. The remainder becomes storm-water runoff and must be collected, stored, absorbed or conveyed elsewhere.

The Southwest Florida Water Management District explains that storm-water systems are specifically designed to collect and manage that runoff. Depending upon the system, water may enter retention areas, detention ponds, swales, catch basins, underground pipes or other drainage facilities. Retention systems allow water to infiltrate into the ground, while detention systems temporarily store water and release it gradually through an outflow structure.

In other words, that lake behind your house may not be there merely because somebody thought waterfront lots would sell for more money. It may be an important piece of your community’s storm-water infrastructure. Your community’s system is only one piece of a much bigger puzzle.

In South Florida, for example, the South Florida Water Management District describes the regional flood-control system as a primary network of canals and natural waterways connected to community drainage districts and hundreds of smaller neighborhood systems. Accordingly, flood control is a shared responsibility involving the District, counties, municipalities, local drainage districts, homeowners’ associations and residents.

That means the storm drain in front of your house is not necessarily the end of the drainage system. It is closer to the beginning.

Think about what happens after rainwater enters the drain on your street. Water collected within a community may move through catch basins, pipes, swales, ponds, lakes and control structures. Depending on the particular system and its permits, some water may infiltrate into the ground, some may be temporarily stored, and some may ultimately discharge downstream.

Each component has a job. But each component also has a limit. A detention pond, for example, is not intended to empty instantaneously. The Southwest Florida Water Management District explains that after a storm, water in a detention pond slowly drains through the pipe in its outflow structure.

There is good reason for that controlled release. Imagine what would happen if every subdivision, shopping center and development could immediately dump all of its storm-water downstream at the same time. The downstream system would have to receive all of it at once.

So, storm-water management is not simply about moving water away from your property as quickly as humanly possible. It is also about storing water, controlling its release, allowing infiltration where appropriate, and managing the rate at which runoff enters downstream systems.

Think about draining a swimming pool. If your swimming pool has one outfall pipe, emptying the pool may take a considerable amount of time. Add several identical pipes with somewhere for the water to go and, naturally, the pool can drain considerably faster.

But now imagine that every home in your neighborhood begins draining its swimming pool at exactly the same time. Then imagine every community surrounding your community does the same thing. Then imagine that the canal, lake, reservoir or other receiving system into which all those pipes ultimately discharge is already full. It no longer matters very much how large your individual drainpipe is. The water has nowhere to go.

That is essentially the problem drainage systems confront during extreme rainfall events. Your neighborhood may be capable of moving water perfectly well under ordinary circumstances. Its storm drains may be clear. Its pipes may be unobstructed. Its lakes may be properly maintained. Its control structures may operate exactly as designed.

But your system still depends upon conditions beyond the boundary of your community. If the downstream receiving system is already carrying tremendous volumes of water, your community cannot simply command its water to disappear.

WHY DOESN’T THE ASSOCIATION JUST PUMP THE WATER OUT?

This is the question that inevitably comes next.

“If the lake is too high, why doesn’t the Association just pump it down?” Pump it where? That is the question. Moving water from Point A accomplishes very little if Point B is already overwhelmed.

If every community responded to a regional flood by indiscriminately pumping its water into the downstream system as quickly as possible, it could simply transfer the problem from one property to another. In addition, storm-water facilities operate under permits and engineered designs governing how water is collected, detained and discharged. The answer ordinarily is not for a homeowners’ association to unilaterally redesign or operate its storm-water system in whatever manner produces the fastest removal of water.

The objective is to manage the water through the system for which the community was designed and permitted.

WHEN EVERYTHING FILLS UP AT ONCE

Here is where Florida’s geography and development become particularly important. As land is developed, natural surfaces are replaced by roofs, roads, sidewalks, driveways and parking lots. Those surfaces do not absorb rainfall the way undeveloped land does.

The South Florida Water Management District explains that urbanization disturbs natural water flow because impervious surfaces reduce the amount of rain that infiltrates into the ground. The resulting increase in runoff volume can overload drainage systems.

That is the heart of the issue. A drainage system has finite storage and conveyance capacity. The community lake has finite storage. The pipes have finite capacity. The control structure has finite discharge capacity. The downstream canal has finite capacity. Wherever the water ultimately goes has physical limits as well.

Extreme rainfall can therefore produce a cascading problem. Water is arriving faster than portions of the drainage network can store, infiltrate or convey it. Once downstream water levels rise sufficiently, drainage upstream necessarily becomes more difficult.

Picture a line of funnels emptying into one another. Everything works beautifully while the bottom funnel can discharge water faster than the funnels above are supplying it. But once the bottom fills, water begins backing up through the system. Making the first funnel bigger does not solve the problem. The bottleneck is downstream.

That concept helps explain one of the most frustrating observations after an extreme storm: the rain may have stopped, but the street is still flooded.

If there is insufficient downstream capacity, drainage takes time. Water has to move through the interconnected system, water levels must fall, ponds and canals must recover storage capacity, and saturated ground may have to absorb or release water.

THEN WHY ARE THE ROADS UNDERWATER?

Because in many storm-water designs, temporary flooding of lower-lying areas can provide storage before water reaches buildings. That may sound crazy to the person looking outside and seeing two feet of water where yesterday there was asphalt, but consider the alternative.

When an extreme storm produces more water than can immediately leave a community, the water has to occupy some space. Between temporarily occupying a street and entering someone’s living room, which would you prefer?

The fact that streets or other low areas are holding water while homes remain dry may therefore tell a very different story from the one residents initially assume. It does not automatically prove that the drainage system failed.

Depending upon the property’s approved storm-water design, temporary storage may be part of how the system protects buildings during unusually severe rainfall.

That said, prolonged or recurring flooding should never simply be dismissed as “normal.” It may warrant review by the appropriate engineer to determine whether drains are obstructed, pipes have failed, elevations or grading have changed, ponds have lost storage capacity, control structures are operating properly, or the system is otherwise functioning according to its permitted design. Maintenance matters.

The Southwest Florida Water Management District recommends routine inspection and maintenance of storm-water infrastructure, including inspection of outfall structures, discharge pipes, inlets, outlets and catch basins, particularly following major storms.

But there is an enormous difference between a drainage system that floods because it has not been properly maintained and a properly functioning drainage system that is temporarily overwhelmed by an extraordinary volume of water. Those two situations should not be confused.

Remember, much of Florida was historically wetlands, marshes and other low-lying land, and living here means accepting that water will always be part of the equation. If you own property in Florida and choose to go without flood insurance, you may as well take a trip to Las Vegas, put your money on the table and roll the dice. And do not make the mistake of believing that because your home is outside a designated high-risk flood zone, you are somehow safe from flooding. FEMA’s current data shows that nearly one-third of National Flood Insurance Program claims from 2014 through 2024 came from outside high-risk flood areas. Most homeowners’ insurance policies do not cover flood damage.

In Florida, particularly after watching fifteen inches of rain fall in a matter of hours, gambling that the water will stop at the flood-zone line may be one bet you simply cannot afford to lose.

With all of the above in mind, before you go pointing fingers at your board of directors, consider pointing them at your legislators instead. If your community experienced flooding and have additional concerns, please be sure to contact your association’s legal counsel.

When Directors’ and Officers’ Insurance Isn’t What You Think It Is

When Directors’ and Officers’ Insurance Isn’t What You Think It Is | A Wake-up Call for Community Association Board Members

Over the last several months, I have encountered several situations in which condominium and homeowners’ association board members were shocked to learn the true nature of the directors’ and officers’ liability coverage they believed was designed to protect them. In each case volunteer board members were named individually in lawsuits filed by dissatisfied owners. Little did they know that after the claims were made, they discovered that the policy they had relied upon did not provide the broad protection they assumed existed.

These board members believed they had purchased traditional directors’ and officers’ liability insurance. Instead, they learned that the policy functioned more like a limited legal defense program than a comprehensive liability policy. The distinction can be significant. When a board member is sued, the expectation is often that the insurance company will not only provide a legal defense but may also cover litigation-related expenses and, when appropriate, pay settlements or judgments. Yet many policies contain extensive limitations, exclusions, conditions, and reimbursement obligations that can dramatically restrict coverage.

The lesson for every community association board is simple: Do not assume your insurance coverage provides protection simply because of the insurance declaration page, which sets out the policy limits. Board members have a fiduciary obligation to understand the scope of the association’s insurance program, particularly the exclusions that may eliminate coverage when it is needed most.

Too often volunteer board members believe insurance matters are being handled by someone else. Some assume their management company has reviewed the coverage. Others assume the association attorney has already analyzed the policy. While managers and attorneys can certainly provide valuable assistance, the responsibility for understanding the association’s insurance program ultimately rests with the board itself.

One recent example is a policy issued by a well-known legal defense insurance company. The policy expressly provides that it is a legal expense policy and not a traditional liability policy. According to the policy language, coverage is triggered only when a claim is made against the insured and the association’s existing insurance coverage has been denied or determined not to apply. The clear language of the policy further established that it does not indemnify the insured for money damages, judgments, or other damages that may be awarded in the lawsuit.

In addition, the policy provided the following:

      • The insurer selects the attorney, not the board.
      • Coverage is limited to a maximum of three claims or lawsuits during a 12-month policy period. (This limitation can be quite problematic during complicated association litigation when multiple members sue.)
      • Coverage is only available after required underlying insurance policies have first been notified and have denied coverage and such denial of notice is provided within a set period of days. (Therefore, even if coverage would otherwise be afforded, if there is a delay in providing the notice of denial from other insurance carriers, the claim can be denied!)

Only a review of the actual insurance policy at issue will determine the extent of the coverage provided. Under many such policies’ limitations and exclusions section, the insureds (meaning either the association and/or the actual board members named in the litigation) remain responsible for numerous litigation expenses. The bare bones “director and officer liability policies” being sold may exclude the following:

      • Expert witness fees and costs
      • Deposition fees and costs
      • Paralegal costs
      • Copies and fax charges
      • Legal research costs
      • Travel expenses within Florida
      • Telephone and long-distance charges
      • Data processing charges
      • Standard U.S. mail postage
      • Transcript costs
      • Court reporter fees
      • Attorney travel expenses outside Florida
      • Trial exhibits
      • Expert witness and nonexpert witness fees
      • Overnight delivery charges
      • Surveillance expenses
      • Investigator fees
      • Service of process fees
      • Court fees and court costs
      • Messenger fees
      • Appeal-related expenses
      • All other litigation-related expenses not specifically assumed by the insurer in the policy.

The policy may even provide that if the insurer advances certain costs, then those amounts may be required to be reimbursed by the insured within 30 days. Failure to reimburse such expenses may result in the insurer ceasing payment of further legal fees associated with the claim! For many associations these expenses can become substantial, particularly in complex litigation requiring expert testimony, extensive discovery, or appeals.

Policy Exclusions Every Board Member Should Understand

Director and officer liability insurance policies can contain numerous exclusions which limit when a defense will be provided. Following are examples:

      • Claims or lawsuits that occurred before the policy’s effective date
      • Lawsuits filed outside the State of Florida
      • Claims not timely reported to the insurer
      • Appellate proceedings and appeals
      • Class action lawsuits
      • Federal court lawsuits, except limited categories involving service animals, emotional support animals, housing discrimination, or Americans with Disabilities Act compliance
      • Claims arising after the policy expiration date
      • Cases in which the insured is the plaintiff
      • Post-judgment proceeding
      • Fair Debt Collection Practices Act claims
      • Claims involving properties not listed as scheduled locations
      • Workers’ compensation-related claims
      • Disability benefit claims
      • ERISA-related (Employee Retirement Income Security Act) claims
      • Unemployment compensation claims
      • Intellectual property disputes involving copyrights, patents, trademarks, trade secrets, or trade dress
      • Environmental damage claims
      • Claims in which the insured employs its own attorney to handle the defense, subject to limited exceptions
      • Claims against current or former board members where the association has sued that board member
      • Claims involving pollution-related allegations
      • Lawsuits between current and former board members suing each other vs. the association suing a former board member
      • Lawsuits where the association is suing its own board members
      • Claims not first reported to underlying insurance carriers in accordance with those policies
      • Claims where the insured declines representation by the insurer’s designated attorney
      • Certain lawsuits between master associations and sub-associations
      • Certain lawsuits between sub-associations
      • Claims exceeding the policy’s three-claim annual limitation
      • Claims involving injuries or deaths arising from specified boating and water-sport activities.

When read together, these exclusions significantly narrow the circumstances under which coverage may be available.

Conditions, Reporting Requirements, and Timely Notice Requirements Can Be Just As Important As Exclusions

One of the most overlooked aspects of insurance policies is that conditions can effectively eliminate coverage even when the claim itself appears covered. For example, a policy may require the following:

      • Existing general liability insurance coverage to remain in force
      • Claims to be reported first to the association’s underlying insurance carriers
      • Written denial letters from those carriers within a specific time period
      • Reporting of those denials to the legal defense insurer within specified time periods
      • Submission of lawsuits within designated reporting deadlines
      • Full cooperation with the appointed attorney.

Failure to satisfy any of these requirements could potentially prevent coverage from being afforded at all. For that reason boards should review not only the exclusions section of every policy but also the conditions, reporting requirements, and notice provisions.

The Danger of Assumptions

The greatest risk facing many boards is assuming coverage exists without reading the policy. Every insurance policy contains exclusions, but are such exclusions reasonable? In light of the exclusions, does the association have proper insurance coverage? At the end of the day, the responsibility for understanding the association’s insurance program ultimately rests with the board itself.

Board members owe fiduciary duties to the community they serve. Part of fulfilling those duties includes developing a working understanding of the association’s insurance protections and limitations. A declaration page and premium invoice tell only a small part of the story. Only the policy itself will set out the exclusions, conditions, endorsements, limitations, and definitions that often determine whether coverage actually exists when a claim arises.

A Final Reminder

Every condominium and homeowners’ association board should schedule a meeting with its insurance agent at least annually. Do not, as so many boards do, just accept whatever policy is being sold. When is the last time your insurance agent asked to meet with the board? When is the last time your board received a detailed review of the insurance coverage provided and their exclusions?

During a meeting with the association’s insurance agent, the board should carefully review not only its directors’ and officers’ coverage but also every insurance policy maintained by the association. Ask what is covered. Ask what is excluded. Ask what conditions must be satisfied before coverage applies. Ask whether endorsements have modified the policy language.

The importance of this review cannot be overstated. Not long ago another community association was stunned to learn that it had no coverage for a significant water loss because prior claims had resulted in a water-damage exclusion being added to its policy. When another casualty event occurred and water migrated throughout a multi-story building, the board discovered there was no insurance coverage for the resulting damage. The exclusion was there all along, but no one had reviewed it. In all likelihood that gap in coverage could have been filled by another insurance provider. But after the casualty occurs, it is far too late.

Insurance policies are contracts. The protection they provide is determined not by assumptions but by the words written on the page. A board that takes the time to understand those words before a claim occurs will be far better prepared than the board that waits until after a lawsuit, casualty loss, or coverage denial arrives. An annual policy review with the association’s insurance agent is not merely a best practice. In today’s increasingly complex insurance environment, it is an essential part of responsible community governance. Remember to also consider inviting the association’s attorney to the meeting with the insurance agent because often your attorney’s expertise will focus on additional inquiry and thereby make the time spent with the insurance agent more worthwhile.

Importance of Having Strong Financial Controls and Policies

Florida’s community associations operate as complex financial and administrative organizations responsible for managing significant budgets, often in the millions of dollars; maintaining shared property; and protecting the financial interests of the owners. With this responsibility comes a board’s fiduciary duty to ensure that financial operations are transparent, accountable, and safeguarded against misuse. In today’s environment where associations face rising costs, increased owner scrutiny, and growing exposure to fraud risks, the need for strong financial policies and controls has never been more important. These four tools form the foundation of responsible financial governance:

i.   A fraud response plan
ii.  A refundable deposit return policy
iii. A conservative reserve investment policy
iv.
Internal control procedures that guide how the association handles money, assets, and decision-making.

These tools are not merely administrative “housekeeping” items; they are essential safeguards that protect the association’s finances, support the board’s fiduciary obligations, and reinforce trust within the community.

i. Fraud prevention (and a proper response to fraud) must be a priority for every association because community associations are uniquely vulnerable due to volunteer leadership, limited staff, and trust-based relationships. Fraud can occur through misappropriation of funds, falsified invoices, vendor “kickbacks,” unauthorized reimbursements, theft of refundable deposits, or manipulation of financial records. A good fraud response plan includes an established, structured, and disciplined approach for responding to suspicious activity. It should begin with a clear statement of purpose, such as the following: “The association treats any suspicion of fraud or any suspected misappropriation of assets seriously, and all instances will be reviewed by the board of directors or others, if necessary.” This sets the tone for a culture of accountability and ensures that concerns are not dismissed or ignored.

A strong fraud response plan ensures that employees know exactly what to do when they observe something unusual. The plan instructs staff to immediately document their concerns in writing, including dates, times, discussions, and any supporting evidence. This protects both the employee and the association by creating a clear record of events. The plan also establishes boundaries by instructing employees not to confront suspected individuals, not to discuss allegations with unauthorized third parties outside the association, and not to conduct their own investigations. These safeguards prevent the mishandling of evidence, reduce liability, and ensure that the board and legal counsel maintain control of the investigative process. Property managers are given a defined role as well. They must listen carefully to concerns, preserve evidence, and escalate the matter to the board instead of attempting to investigate on their own without clear authority and parameters established by the board. A fraud response plan is not simply a procedural document; it is a critical internal control that protects the association from financial loss, protects employees from retaliation, and protects the board from claims of negligence or mishandling.

ii. Refundable deposits are another area where associations must have clear procedures. Many Florida associations collect refundable deposits for tenant/leasing issues, move-ins, move-outs, and unit alterations. These deposits are intended to protect the association from damage to common elements or violations of construction rules. However, without a formal policy, associations risk losing track of deposits, failing to return them in a timely manner, or violating the applicable Florida Statutes concerning return of deposits. A comprehensive, refundable deposit return policy establishes clear procedures for determining when a deposit is refundable, how notice must be provided, how long the payer has to claim the funds, and what happens to the funds if they remain unclaimed. For instance, if a deposit is collected by the association in connection with a lease of a condominium unit, the association must ensure its policies strictly adhere to the requirements of section 83.49(3), F.S., as it relates to making a formal claim upon the deposit if damage occurs, as well as the required timing to return a deposit if no claim is being made.

iii. A conservative reserve investment policy is a critical component of an association’s overall financial governance and fiduciary responsibility.

A conservative reserve investment policy—typically emphasizing preservation of principal, liquidity, and minimal risk (e.g., federally insured accounts, treasury instruments, and similarly stable vehicles)—aligns with the board’s fiduciary duty to safeguard association assets. Reserve funds function as the association’s financial safety net, designed to cover substantial, non-recurring expenditures such as roof replacements, elevator overhauls, and structural repairs. Because these obligations are often predictable in timing but significant in amount, exposing reserve funds to market volatility or speculative investment strategies can undermine the association’s ability to meet its statutory and operational obligations when they come due and could even lead to claims of breach of fiduciary duty.

Equally important, a conservative reserve investment policy mitigates the risk of special assessments and financial shock to unit owners. If reserve funds are diminished due to investment losses, the association may be forced to levy substantial special assessments to fund required repairs, creating immediate financial burdens for owners and potential collection issues for the association. Maintaining conservatively invested reserves contributes to the long-term stability and marketability of units/homes. Well-funded and properly managed reserves are widely viewed as an indicator of sound governance, which can positively affect property values, lender confidence, and purchaser demand. Conversely, underfunded or poorly managed reserves—especially if tied to investment losses—can lead to deferred maintenance, diminished property conditions, and reputational harm to the community. In sum, a conservative reserve investment policy is not merely a financial preference; it is a legally grounded risk-management strategy that protects the association and its members.

iv. Internal control procedures are the systems and procedures that prevent fraud, ensure accuracy, and promote accountability. Such internal controls can include the following:

    • The fixed asset capitalization policy
    • The conflict of interest disclosure statement

The fixed asset capitalization policy ensures that capital expenditures are properly categorized and accounted for. It clarifies the difference between repairs and improvements for accounting purposes. For example, repairing a roof leak with modern materials may be considered an “improvement” for accounting purposes, but a “repair” for legal purposes. This distinction matters because misclassification can distort financial statements, reserve studies, and budget planning.

The conflict of interest disclosure statement is another essential internal control. Generally, a rebuttable presumption of a conflict exists if a director or officer (or family member of a director or officer) enters into a contract with the association or has a financial interest in a business that does. A conflict of interest disclosure policy ensures transparency and protects the board from allegations of self-dealing. Together with the fraud response plan and the refundable deposit return policy, these internal controls create a comprehensive system of checks and balances that strengthen financial oversight and reduce risk.

Florida’s community associations face increasing financial pressures and heightened expectations for transparency and accountability. Policies are only effective if they are properly adopted and communicated. A comprehensive fraud response plan, a well-structured refundable deposit return policy, a conservative reserve investment policy, and strong internal control procedures are essential tools for meeting these challenges. These policies reduce the risk of fraud, ensure compliance with Florida law, promote fairness and transparency, strengthen financial reporting, and help protect the board and the association from liability. By adopting and consistently applying these policies, associations create a culture of integrity and trust along with a financially healthy community.

If you have questions regarding these financial policies, please reach out to your association’s attorney and/or a qualified and licensed CPA experienced in such matters and in what are referred to in accounting terms as “common interest realty associations” (a/k/a CIRA).

Accusations Of Racial Discrimination by the HOA

Admittedly there are always two sides to every story. This is why we have the American judicial system to get to the resolution of a matter as decided by the “trier of fact,” be it the judge or jury, after hearing from both the accuser and the accused (or in civil terms, hearing from the plaintiff and defendant). In most civil cases a plaintiff only needs to prove that a particular event was more likely than not to have occurred. This is referred to as a “preponderance of the evidence” standard of proof, meaning that a majority of the evidence favors the plaintiff’s position. But, before the parties can get to that stage, the plaintiff first must sufficiently allege a cause of action against the defendant. If not, then the plaintiff’s lawsuit is subject to being dismissed. Well, that is exactly what happened in the recent federal appellate case of Watts v. Joggers Run Property Owners Association, Inc., 133 F.4th 1032 (11th Cir. 2025), in which the plaintiff, Watts, appealed the dismissal of her case in its entirety by the lower court, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida.

In the underlying action, Watts alleged Joggers Run of taking unlawful actions against her, her family, and her guests due to their race and brought claims against Joggers Run under both the Fair Housing Act and the Civil Rights Act. Watts accused Joggers Run of selectively enforcing its rules pertaining to parking, pets, yard sales, and penalty fees against her and her family but not against non-Black residents. She accused the association’s president of referring to Black people as “monkeys” and another director of using derogatory, race-based comments. She alleged that she was limited to three minutes when addressing the board, but other non-Black owners were not so limited; and when she complained about this, somehow the board stripped her of her board membership without any notice to her. She alleged that the association denied her children use of the basketball courts because a director complained about there being noisy Black kids and “too many people of color” using the basketball courts. She alleged that the association accused her Black guest of trespassing and vandalizing cars. Other discriminatory practices were alleged in the lawsuit as well.

Joggers Run moved to dismiss the entire complaint for failure to raise any cognizable claim under both the Fair Housing Act and the Civil Rights Act. The lower district court granted that motion. While the lower court found that the alleged conduct of Joggers Run was reprehensible, it nevertheless ruled that none of Watts’s allegations could support her statutory claims and dismissed the lawsuit. Watts then appealed the dismissal to the U.S. Court of Appeals of the Eleventh Circuit, which ultimately reversed the lower court’s dismissal and remanded the parties back to the lower court for further
proceedings.

The standard of review employed by the Appellate Court is, in this instance, de novo, meaning the Appellate Court reviews the matter as if it were being considered for the first time, allowing for a new analysis of the facts and law involved. The Appellate Court noted that to withstand a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim, the plaintiff’s complaint must include enough facts to state a claim for relief that is plausible on its face. The plaintiff must allege more than mere conclusions and formulaic recitations of the elements of a cause of action. But, however, in Fair Housing Act discrimination cases, the Appellate Court recognized that it can be difficult to define the precise formulation of a required prima facie case before the process of discovery has an opportunity to unearth all the relevant facts and evidence. That said, the allegations in the complaint should be judged by the required statutory elements.

The Appellate Court began its discussion with a brief history and the importance of the Fair Housing Act. As found by a bipartisan committee appointed by President Lyndon B. Johnson, national fair housing laws were necessary to end evident and profoundly divisive housing discrimination. In response, Congress passed the Fair Housing Act in 1968 to provide for fair housing within the United States; and in Sections 1981 and 1982 of the Civil Rights Act, Congress provided that all Americans, regardless of race, are entitled to equal contract and property rights.

While the Fair Housing Act makes it unlawful to discriminate against any person in the terms, conditions, or privileges of the sale or rental of a dwelling or in the provision of services or facilities in connection therewith because of race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin, Congress did not provide a list as to what these “terms, conditions, and privileges” actually are. Later, through adoption of regulations by U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development under the Fair Housing Act, we learn that access to communal spaces is within the scope of “terms, conditions, and privileges” of the sale or rental of a dwelling and that limiting the use of such privileges because of race would be a violation of the Fair Housing Act. In other words, when a person enters into an enforceable agreement for the purchase of property that includes a mandatory obligation to be a member of a homeowners’ association, then discrimination is prohibited as related to any of the privileges, services, and facilities afforded by membership in the homeowners’ association. The Appellate Court found that Watt’s complaint sufficiently alleged that she was denied equal access and treatment because of her race by Joggers Run.

In examining whether Watts had sufficient allegations to withstand the motion to dismiss regarding the Civil Rights Act, the Appellate Court found that it only needed to “initially identify an impaired contractual relationship under which Watts had rights.” The Appellate Court found, “The HOA rules created an enforceable contract that governed the residence rights and responsibilities and benefits of membership.” Because Watts alleged that the HOA violated its own rules and regulations by allowing non-Black residents to violate the rules and regulations while enforcing the rules and regulations against her and her family due to their race, Watts plausibly alleged that the contractual relationship was violated by Joggers Run in contravention of its own rules and regulations, which was sufficient to bring such a lawsuit. In fact, the United States Supreme Court broadly construes the Civil Rights Act to protect not merely the enforceability of property interest acquired by Black citizens but also their right to use property on an equal basis with White citizens.

Watts alleged that the Joggers Run created a dual property system where White owners could fully enjoy the amenities’ common areas and services while Watts, as a Black resident, could not. In conclusion the Appellate Court found that Watts’s complaint presented plausible claims for relief under the Fair Housing Act and under the relevant sections of the Civil Rights Act. Therefore, the case was reinstated and remanded back to the lower court for further proceedings.

Given that the facts of the case have yet to be tried in court, whether racial discrimination occurred against Watts remains to be heard and determined by the trier of fact. All that we know for the time being is that Watts has sufficiently stated her complaint to make a primary showing of discrimination, but whether it actually occurred or not will have to be decided later after all relevant evidence and testimony is reviewed by the trier of fact.

Reviewing the alleged facts in a light most favorable to and as presented by Watts, it certainly seems as though discrimination may have occurred. However, could Joggers Run have accomplished the car towing, the closing of the basketball court, and its other actions in a lawful, non-discriminatory manner? The short answer is, “likely so,” if it had equally enforced its rules and regulations against all owners and followed the required procedures. Had Joggers Run equally enforced its rules and regulations and followed the required procedures, then Watts’s claims could have failed.

Regardless of equal enforcement, making disparaging comments regarding any member’s race, color, religion, sex, familial status, or national origin is not only fundamentally wrong but also sets the stage for all the board members’ acts to be judged with those racially charged comments in mind. To make such comments as a board member could be, if proven true, fatal to the association’s position. Had the Joggers Run board members not made racially motivated comments, if it did as alleged by Watts, and had they engaged the association’s attorney to provide important and necessary guidance, then in all likelihood this entire fiasco could have been avoided.

Board Member Fiduciary Duties Owed to the Association

What is the standard of care that a community association officer and board member owe to their association? The Homeowners’ Association Act (Ch. 720 Fla. Stat.) provides in §720.303, “The officers and directors of an association are subject to §617.0830 and have a fiduciary relationship to the members who are served by the association.” The Condominium Act (Ch. 718 Fla. Stat.)  in §718.111 similarly provides, “The officers and directors of the association have a fiduciary relationship to the owners.”  Still, though, there is no express definition of the term “fiduciary relationship” set out in either piece of legislation.

With that in mind, let’s take a look at some of the more common definitions of the term “fiduciary,” including the following:

      • A fiduciary relationship is a relation between two parties wherein one party (fiduciary) has the duty to act in the best interest of the other party (beneficiary or principal).
      • A fiduciary is a person who holds a legal or ethical relationship of trust with one or more other parties. Typically, a fiduciary prudently takes care of money or other assets for another person.
      • A fiduciary duty is a relationship in which one party places special trust, confidence, and reliance in and is influenced by another who has a fiduciary duty to act for the benefit of the party.
      • Most importantly, and germane to this discussion, a fiduciary is a person or organization that acts on behalf of another person or persons, putting their clients’ interests ahead of their own, with a duty to preserve good faith and trust.

From all of this we can glean that a good community association board member puts the interest of their association well above their own personal interests. Not only are homeowners’ associations subject to Chapter 720, Florida Statutes, and condominium associations subject to Chapter 718, Florida Statutes, but both are subject to Florida’s Not-For-Profit Corporation Act, Chapter 617, Florida Statutes. Section 617.0830, Fla. Stat., provides a mechanism that will shield a director from breach of fiduciary duty claims so long as they follow the requirements set forth in this ever-important piece of legislation.

Section 617.0830, Fla. Stat., provides,

A director shall discharge his or her duties as a director, including his or her duties as a member of a committee, In good faith;

With the care an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would exercise under similar circumstances; and

In a manner he or she reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation.

In discharging his or her duties, a director may rely on information, opinions, or reports, including financial statements and other financial data, if prepared or presented by the following:

One or more officers or employees of the corporation whom the director reasonably believes to be reliable and competent in the matters presented;

Legal counsel, public accountants, or other persons as to matters the director reasonably believes are within the persons’ professional or expert competence; or

A committee of the board of directors of which he or she is not a member if the director reasonably believes the committee merits confidence.

A director is not acting in good faith if he or she has knowledge concerning the matter in question that makes reliance otherwise permitted by i, ii, and iii immediately above unwarranted. (In plain English and for example, this means if you have reason to know that you should not rely on such professional advice because say the expert was impaired, then relying on his or her advice will not provide the statutory protection.)

A director is not liable for any action taken as a director, or any failure to take any action, if he or she performed the duties of his or her office in compliance with all of the aforementioned.

Therefore, for example, should the association’s legal counsel or other selected expert in a particular field provide advice to the association’s board and then the board member decides to act in a contrary manner, then such board member would not have the aforesaid statutory protection and, in fact, could be accused of acting in bad faith should they act in a manner contrary to the advice or instruction of the expert.

Condominium association directors should be aware that pursuant to §781.112, Fla. Stat., a willful and knowing failure to complete the structural integrity reserve study and/ or the milestone inspection when required to do so is considered to be an automatic breach of such officer’s and director’s fiduciary relationship to the unit owners. Yikes!

Additionally, the “business judgment rule” protects board members from their decision making so long as the board member acted in such a manner as would any other reasonably prudent person under similar circumstances. Generally, the decisions of directors are not subject to successful attack unless there is a showing of fraud, criminal activity, self-dealing, dishonesty, or incompetency. In fact, in the often-cited seminal case Sonny Boy, L.L.C. v. Asnani, 879 So. 2d 25, 28 (Fla. 5th DCA 2004), the court held that the directors of a condominium association were not personally liable for failing to maintain and repair common elements where the accusation was that rental revenue was lost as a result thereof because there was no showing of fraud, self-dealing, or unjust enrichment.

The Sonny Boy court went even further when it wrote in its opinion that “it is well established in Florida that absent fraud, self-dealing and betrayal of trust, directors of condominium associations are not personally liable for the decisions they make in their capacity as directors of condominium associations.” See, e.g., Perlow v. Goldberg, 700 So.2d 148 (Fla. 3d DCA 1997) (finding directors of condominium associations not individually liable for actions and governance of condominium association); Taylor v. Wellington Station Condominium Association, Inc., 633 So.2d 43 (Fla. 5th DCA 1994) (finding that in general, corporate directors and officers cannot be personally liable for corporate acts absent actual wrongdoing in the form of fraud, self-dealing, or unjust enrichment to trigger individual liability); Munder v. Circle One Condominium, Inc., 596 So.2d 144 (Fla. 4th DCA 1992) (reversing lower court’s finding of individual liability by condominium developer). Similarly, §617.0834(1), Florida Statutes  (2002), and §607.0831(1), Florida Statutes (2002),[2] provide insulation for condominium association directors from liability in their individual capacities absent fraud, criminal activity, self-dealing, or unjust enrichment. Perlow, 700 So.2d at 149.”

In Grand Harbour Community Association, Inc. v. G.H. Vero Beach Development, LLC., Case No. 4D2023-1191, (Fla. 4th DCA Oct. 2, 2024), the trial court had found that the developer and the developer-appointed directors were entitled to summary judgment on the breach of fiduciary duty claim because no evidence existed that the developer-appointed directors had acted in bad faith in failing to fund the reserves or in undercharging the developer for its deficit funding obligation, and therefore there was no basis to hold the developer vicariously liable for the acts of its appointed directors. Then, on appeal, the 4th District Court of Appeal affirmed the trial court ruling because “the community association declaration provided that the board members shall not be liable for any mistake of judgment, negligent or otherwise, except for their own individual willful misfeasance, malfeasance, misconduct, or bad faith.””

The appealate court continued, “Under Florida law, the ‘business judgment rule’ protects directors of non-profit corporations, from personal liability for any actions undertaken as directors ‘absent a showing of bad faith, self-dealing, or a violation of criminal law,’” citing New Horizons Condo. Master Ass’n. v. Harding, 336 So. 3d 796, 799 (Fla. 3d DCA 2022).

In yet another case, Miller v. Homeland Prop. Owners Association, Inc., 284 So. 3d 534, 537 (Fla. 4th DCA 2019), the court held that deference to community associations’ decisions must be given when i) the association had the contractual or statutory authority to perform the relevant acts; and ii) the board acted reasonably and not in an arbitrary, capricious manner or in bad faith.

So, while Florida Statutes and relevant case law provide a strong level of protection in favor of officer and board member decision making, such decisions should be rendered reasonably, in reliance on expert opinions (when relevant), and not decided in bad faith or in an arbitrary and capricious manner or in a manner that suggests self-dealing or unjust enrichment, etc. in favor of the officer and director(s).

Not all Expenditures Can Be Collected from Delinquent Owners as Part of the Collection/Foreclosure Process – Why Not?

It is clear that Florida’s community association collection/foreclosure legislation allows associations to foreclose an owner’s home for nonpayment of assessments. However, not all of the monies expended by an association fit into the definition of an assessment. For example, let’s say that an association has a right to correct a deficiency on an owner’s lot, but the declaration of covenants at issue does not support converting the money spent into an assessment. In that event, the monies expended by the association would have to be recovered as part of a breach of contract action rather than as part of an assessment/foreclosure action. Sometimes, however, the declaration will provide that the monies expended can be treated as an assessment. If that is the case, then before those expenditures can be included as a part of the collection/foreclosure process, the board would need to convert the expenditure into an assessment against the noncomplying owner. (As to how that is done, you can discuss it with your community association’s attorney.) Florida’s collection/foreclosure legislation also provides for recovery of certain costs incidental to the collection/foreclosure process, but recovery of such cost must be rooted in a statute or by contract (i.e., the declaration of covenants).

Let’s look at the fee charged by a management company for sending the notice of late assessment letter, often referred as a NOLA letter, as required by Florida Statute, and determine whether it is a recoverable cost in an association’s collection/foreclosure action and whether including the NOLA fee as a part of the association’s collection/foreclosure proceedings violates the Federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (the Act).

The Act was passed into law because of abundant evidence of the use of abusive, deceptive, and unfair debt collection practices. It does not matter whether a debt collector used their best efforts to comply with the Act. Only strict compliance matters when it comes to the enforceability of the Act against a debt collector. Clearly, the association is not considered a “debt collector” pursuant to the Act and, for the most part, neither are management companies, with this caveat: the pendulum may swing in the future to the notion that management companies are, in fact, debt collectors. It seems that at least for the time being they are shielded from the Act. However, what is patently clear is that an attorney who provides collection/foreclosure services to assist their association clients with delinquent assessments is certainly considered a “debt collector.” Therefore, the attorney must be vigilant when reviewing the delinquent owner’s account ledger to ensure that the items set out in the ledger can lawfully be included in the association’s collection/foreclosure action. A recent case reminds us of this fact.

On February 4, 2025, in Glover v. Ocwen Loan Servicing, Case no. 23-12578 & 12579 (11th Cir. Fla. 2025), the 11th Circuit of the Federal Court of Appeals found that Ocwen as a debt collector violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act when it charged consumers an optional fee when making expedited mortgage payments because the loan servicer charged an amount that was not expressly authorized by the agreement creating the debt or permitted by law. The takeaway from this case is that a debt collector can only collect debts that are authorized by law or by contract with the debtor.

It was only several years ago that the Florida legislature enacted into law the requirement that an association assessment debtor must be provided the NOLA correspondence from the association providing the debtor a final opportunity to pay their delinquent assessment debt prior to turning the matter over to the association’s legal counsel to commence collection/foreclosure proceedings where fees and costs accrue against the debtor. See S. 718.121 and S. 720.3085, Fla. Stat.

Management companies are typically tasked with preparing and sending the NOLA letter on behalf of the associations they manage before turning the file over for collections to the association’s attorney. In this regard, a management company that is charging such a fee but has not amended its contract with the association to provide for charging the fee for the notice of late assessment would be wise to consider amending its contract with the association they represent to provide for this charge. Doing so would ensure that the management company, even though it may not be considered a “debt collector,” would have a solid basis for charging the fee because it would be based on a contractual obligation charged to the association. This is important because the NOLA, as mandated by Florida Statutes, does not at all provide for the recovery of a fee in regard to sending such a letter. So, while management companies may not be considered a “debt collector” today, this could change in any new case at any time. Why take the chance?

Now, let’s analyze whether the attorney who is collecting the past due assessment debts for the association can include the management company’s NOLA fee paid by the association to the management company in the collection/foreclosure action against a delinquent owner. Keep in mind, as we go through the analysis, that the “debt collector” (in this case, the attorney) can only collect debts authorized by contract or by law, and also remember that the relevant laws governing the NOLA letter do not provide for a specific cost recovery for the management company sending of the notice of late assessment letter. Thus, at a minimum, there should at least be a contractual obligation that the association pay the management company for sending the NOLA letter. But that may not always be the case even though it is the better practice.

Part and parcel with the collection/foreclosure process is the recording of an association assessment lien. To be valid, such a claim of lien must state the description of the parcel, the name of the record owner, the name and address of the association, the assessment amount due, and the due date. The claim of lien secures all unpaid assessments that are due and that may accrue subsequent to the recording of the claim of lien and before entry of a certificate of title, as well as interest, late charges, and reasonable costs and attorneys’ fees incurred by the association incident to the collection process.

So, while the relevant statutes do not provide for the association to be able to recover a fee for the sending of the NOLA letter, it certainly should be considered a “reasonable cost incurred by the association incident to the collection process,” most especially when the fee charged for sending the NOLA letter is a contractual obligation between the association and the management company.

There even exists an argument that, even if the management contract between the association and the management company does not provide that the association is responsible to pay the management company for the preparation and sending of the notice of late assessment, it is still considered a “reasonable cost”; but when you plug in the holding of the aforementioned case, the collection of the cost associated with the NOLA letter by the debt collector (i.e., the attorney representing the association), the better practice is to ensure that the contract between the management company and the association contains a provision that the association is responsible to pay the management company a reasonable fee for each such notice of late assessment letter sent.

Perhaps now you have a better understanding of why, at times, the association’s collection/foreclosure attorney cannot include a particular line item on the delinquent owner’s account ledger in the collection/foreclosure action. If you have any questions regarding the collection/foreclosure process, most especially which charges can and cannot be included, please be sure to discuss them with your association’s attorney.

U.S. Treasury Department Announces Suspension of Enforcement of the CTA

U.S. Treasury Department Announces the Suspension of Enforcement of the Corporate Transparency Act Against U.S. Citizens and Domestic Reporting Companies

Keeping up with the “on again, off again” requirements of the Corporate Transparency Act is like watching a basketball bounce up and down. Finally, however, it appears as though the point guard took the shot and the basket is made.

On March 2, 2025, The Treasury Department announced that, with respect to the Corporate Transparency Act, not only will it NOT enforce any penalties or fines associated with the beneficial ownership information reporting rule under the existing regulatory deadlines, but it will further NOT enforce any penalties or fines against U.S. citizens or domestic reporting companies or their beneficial owners after the forthcoming rule changes take effect either.

The Treasury Department will further be issuing a proposed rulemaking that will narrow the scope of the rule to foreign reporting companies only. Treasury takes this step in the interest of supporting hard-working American taxpayers and small businesses and ensuring that the rule is appropriately tailored to advance the public interest.

“This is a victory for common sense,” said U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent. “Today’s action is part of President Trump’s bold agenda to unleash American prosperity by reining in burdensome regulations, in particular for small businesses that are the backbone of the American economy.”

You can view the official Press Release HERE.

It was also rumored that the Executive branch made an announcement that the United States Treasury will be suspending all future enforcement of the Corporate Transparency Act on American businesses and is working towards an emergency rule for codification of the new enforcement policy in furtherance of its goals toward less governmental regulation.

As new information is obtained we will share it with you, our readers.

Thinking of Filing a New Lawsuit?

Thinking of Filing a New Lawsuit?

The Florida Supreme Court approved multiple substantial amendments to the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure that went into effect on January 1, 2025. While these changes are significant, they do not appear to be terribly overwhelming. This article is not intended to provide a comprehensive review of these changes but rather to point out some of the more interesting changes. It is important to note that these new procedural amendments to the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure only apply to lawsuits filed on or after January 1, 2025. In speaking with several litigators about these new rules, their takeaway is that a plaintiff best be ready for trial when filing your lawsuit. They say this because of the new discovery rules that fast track the process.

Courts now have the authority to extend deadlines for responding to motions either with or without a formal motion and with or without notice. This increased flexibility should streamline procedural timelines and reduce delays. Litigants may find that the court is not as willing to grant such motions as it was in days gone by.

Newly filed cases must be assigned to one of three tracks: complex, general, or stream-lined within 120 days of the filing date. Each of the three tracks has their own unique deadlines for filing and service of motions, etc., ensuring that the cases are managed according to their complexity.

Deadlines outlined in case management orders, which must be issued by the relevant court within 120 days of the commencement of action, will be strictly enforced unless modified by a court order. Obtaining extensions for these deadlines will be more challenging and limited to extraordinary circumstances only.

Courts can schedule case management conferences either on their own initiative or upon proper notice by a party. When a party requests such a conference, it must outline all specific issues to be addressed and provide a list of all pending motions. Failure to include unresolved motions may result in those motions never being heard by the court, highlighting the importance of thorough preparation.

Interestingly, motions for summary judgment and motions requiring an evidence hearing may be heard at case management conferences upon agreement of the parties. Attorneys are now expected to enter the courtroom prepared to make decisions and enter binding agreements regarding motions, issues, and scheduling. The excuse  “I need to check with my client” does not seem as though it will suffice any longer.

Failure to attend a case management conference can lead to serious consequences, including the dismissal of the action, striking of pleadings, or limitations on witness testimonies.

When filing a motion that is not dispositive of the case (a dispositive motion is a motion to dismiss or motion for summary judgment), the moving party must file a statement with the court certifying that they conferred with the opposing party and whether the opposing party agrees on a resolution of the motion or not.

Certain discovery disclosures must be made within a 60-day window after service of the complaint is completed, and discovery cannot commence before these initial disclosure obligations are satisfied unless otherwise provided for by court order.

Objections to interrogatories must be stated with specificity including the actual reasons for objecting, and if done incorrectly such objections can be considered waived. The same goes for production of documents required by subpoena.

Motions to continue the trial date are now disfavored and should be rarely granted except upon a showing of good cause.

The deadline to respond to a motion for summary judgment is 40 days after service of the motion. A hearing on the motion must be scheduled at least 10 days after the response deadline. Due to previously congested court calendars, it has been nearly impossible to schedule hearings promptly. Hopefully this will no longer be the case.

The Florida Supreme Court hopes that the adoption of these changes to the Florida Rules of Civil Procedure will streamline cases to help avoid backlogs, to provide for more timely hearing of motions, and most importantly to keep the case on track for the intended trial date unless the case is settled sooner.

Only time will determine whether these procedural changes achieve their intended effects. The legal community will no doubt closely monitor the implementation and impact of these amendments on the efficiency and effectiveness of Florida’s civil litigation process.

What is the takeaway from all of the above information? Well, those in the know say that the plaintiff in any newly filed a litigation better have all of their ducks in a row before they file their lawsuit. Failure to be prepared in this fashion could be disastrous. Stay tuned for further updates and analyses as these rules take effect and are applied in practice. Of course, your association’s attorney can also explain these procedural changes to you as they may relate to your association’s litigation.

Written by Jeffrey Rembaum, Esq. Reprinted with permission as it appears in the February 2025 issue of the Florida Community Association Journal.

The Consequences of Failing to Maintain The Official Records

The Consequences of Failing to Maintain the Official Records

The following scenario happens all too often. A member makes a written records request to inspect the official records of the association and proceeds to provide a laundry list of documents that the member wants to inspect. In response, the association may arrange to have the member come to the property management office to inspect the records or, if the laundry list is not extensive, provide the requested records to the member by making copies or providing them electronically. Sometimes, however, associations do not always maintain official records in accordance with the requirements of Chapters 718 and 720, Fla. Stat., and an association may argue that it gave the member what it could, so that is all that really matters, right? Wrong! If your association operates this way, you are in for a surprise.

In the case of William Pecchia and Kathleen Porter v. Wayside Estates Home Owners Association, Inc., 388 So. 2d 1136 (Fla. 5th DCA 2024), litigation initially arose between the homeowners (Pecchia and Porter) and the association due to the belief by Pecchia that the association was failing to maintain the common area and that the association was not enforcing violations. Pecchia observed that over the years the association lowered annual assessments and seemed to spend less money on maintenance despite observable deteriorating conditions to the property.

Accordingly, Pecchia requested to inspect the association’s records including copies of several years’ worth of insurance policies and certain records relating to the association’s upkeep of lots and common areas, including financial statements, canceled checks, and bank statements. The association did not respond to Pecchia’s records request in the statutory timeframe of 10 working days, and when it finally did respond, only copies of some of the requested records were provided. Eventually Pecchia submitted a renewed request for records, and then the parties negotiated for several months to no avail. Finally Pecchia filed for injunctive relief against the association. Initially Pecchia was unsuccessful in convincing the trial court that the association failed to maintain and produce requested records and was unsuccessful in obtaining an injunction against the association mandating that the requested records be provided. She appealed.

However, on appeal the Appellate Court found the following:

      1. The association did not sufficiently comply with the requirements of section 720.303, Fla. Stat., (which pertains to HOA official records requests); and
      2. The association did not sufficiently comply with its obligations to maintain its common area and properly enforce violations of the governing documents.

During the trial court proceedings, in regard to whether the association sufficiently complied with section 720.303, Fla. Stat., the trial court found that the association did not provide copies of requested insurance policies but that the association was not statutorily required to provide requested bank statements and canceled checks because section 720.303(4), Fla. Stat., only requires that an association maintain “accounting records.” Despite the lack of the association providing all of the records requested by Pecchia, the trial court found that the association had provided “sufficient documents in response to the Plaintiff’s request.” Further, while the trial court found that while the requested records were not provided within the statutory timeline, the association was not in violation because “sufficient” documents were eventually provided to Pecchia’s request. The appellate court disagreed!

On appeal, the appellate court found that the trial court misinterpreted section 720.303(4)-(5), Fla. Stat., when it held that the association had sufficiently complied with the statute. In short the appellate court found that the use of the word “shall” in the foregoing sections meant that there was no flexibility in the association’s obligation to maintain records provided for in section 720.303(4) and to permit inspection in accordance with section 720.303(5). The appellate court went on to discuss the meaning of the word “shall” (i.e., being mandatory) and the meaning of the word “may” (i.e., being permissive).

Additionally, the appellate court discussed that pursuant to other subsections of section 720.303, Fla. Stat., financial penalties are provided for beginning on the 11th business day in which an association does not make records available. In the aforementioned case, although the association ended up providing (or making available for inspection) some of Pecchia’s requested records, it did not provide access to all of Pecchia’s requested records, including insurance records, bank statements, and canceled checks, all of which the appellate court held would be “included in the financial and accounting records which a homeowners’ association is required to maintain.” Additionally, the records provided were provided after the statutory deadline. As stated by the appellate court,

“[S]ections 720.303(4) and (5) do not provide for substantial compliance. Rather, the language of the statute clearly provides that a homeowners’ association “shall” (1) maintain all items enumerated in 720.303(4) and (2) make them available to the homeowners within ten business days upon request [for inspection or by providing the records requested]. This language is mandatory.”

In regard to finding that the association did not maintain the common areas, there is scant mention as to why the appellate court found this to be the case.

Those involved with homeowners’ associations should also be aware of some recent legislative changes that became effective and pertain to official records and are incorporated into the most recent revision to section 720.303, Fla. Stat. For example, by January 1, 2025, an association with 100 or more parcels is required to post many, but not all, of its official records on its website or make such documents available through an application that can be downloaded on a mobile device. Additionally, homeowners’ associations are now required to maintain most of their official records for a period of seven  years unless the governing documents of the association provide for a longer period of time. Also, homeowners’ associations must adopt written rules governing the method or policy by which the official records of the association are to be retained and the time period such records must be retained.

For those involved with condominium associations, there are also some recent legislative changes pertaining to official records that became effective and are incorporated into the most recent revision to section 718.111, Fla. Stat. For example, by January 1, 2026, an association managing a condominium with 25 or more units—which does not contain timeshare units—shall post copies of its official records on its website or app. If official records are posted on the association’s website or app, the association may direct the unit owner or their authorized representative to the website or app (at this time HOAs may not do similarly). Clarification is provided that email addresses and fax numbers are only accessible to unit owners if such owner has consented to receive their official notices by electronic transmission or has personally indicated that such personal information may be shared with other unit owners. Official records now include all invoices, transaction receipts, or deposit slips that substantiate any receipt or expenditure of funds by the association, copies of building permits, and all satisfactorily completed board member educational certificates. Additionally, official records must now be maintained in an organized manner that facilitates inspection by a unit owner. A condominium association must now provide a checklist of all records made available for inspection and copying along with records that were not made available to the requester. The condominium association must retain the checklist provided to every requesting member for at least seven  years. If a director, board member, or manager knowingly, willfully, and repeatedly (i.e., two or more times in a 12-month period) fails to provide official records, such person commits a misdemeanor of the second degree. Finally, if a person willfully and knowingly refuses to release official records with the intent to avoid or escape detection, arrest, trial, or punishment, then it is the equivalent of a felony of the third degree.

To conclude, all community associations should be diligent, prompt, and thorough in responding to official records requests. While associations are not required to “cherry pick” and provide specific records that a member demands to inspect, associations have the obligation to maintain the official records and provide an opportunity for members to inspect the official records. If you are unsure of which records must be posted to the association’s website, or if you are in doubt as to your association’s responsibility in regard to official records and official record requests, then be sure to consult with your association counsel regarding these important responsibilities.

Reprinted with permission as it appears in the January 2025 issue of the Florida Community Association Journal.